Editor's note: Ito Sensei's article was originally published in the online magazine El Budoka 2.0 and was kindly translated by Santiago Almaraz Sensei. Read the Spanish version here: Un Buen Prfesor ES

A Good Teacher is…

A while back, a person came to the dojo and asked me if we needed a teacher. They had a friend who was 4th Dan and wanted to move to the US. In their country, they didn’t have a dojo, nor did they have any students but were looking to move to the US and start teaching. The thing I found interesting is that this person’s business card had the title of “teacher” but they didn’t have any students and were only 4th Dan. I politely declined and laughed after I closed the door. I laughed because of the audacity. I am 6th Dan and the Chief Instructor, and I still don’t think I am worthy of the title of “teacher.”

In the west, in a vocational sense, the title of teacher is ranked above instructor or coach. A teacher is “a person who helps others learn, an instructor by profession, and a guide who shares knowledge.” An instructor is “a person whose job is to teach a skill, subject, or activity. The term commonly applies to teachers of practical tasks, entry-level college educators, or sports trainers.”

In Japanese traditional arts, an instructor or shihan (師範) is above the title of sensei (先生) or teacher. In traditional training arts, the title of coach isn’t typically used unless the art is also a sport like in Judo.

The title Shihan is made up of two characters: (師) teacher or master and (範) model. Ideally, with this definition, Shihan is a teacher who is the exemplary model of what the students should be striving to become. Sensei is also two characters: (先) before and (生) life. Essentially, a Sensei is the “one who has come before you.” Thus, a Sensei can be thought of as a guide on the path since they have been where you are now.

There are other also many other teaching titles depending on the art like Hanshi (範士), Kyoshi (教士), Renshi (錬士) and Soke (宗家). These titles all have their meanings and eligibilities and are supposed to suggest that the holder be a higher and higher level of teacher.

In 2009, Google launched Project Oxygen in an attempt to determine what makes a manager great and gathered over 10,000 observations with over 100 different variables. It identified these 10 key behaviors of highly effective Google managers: 1) Be a good coach, 2) Empower the team without micromanaging, 3) Create a team environment that values everyone, 4) Focus on productivity and results, 5) Communicate effectively, 6) Support career development and discuss performance, 7) Implement clear vision and strategy, 8) Have key technical skills, 9) Collaborate effectively across the organization, and 10) Make strong decisions.

When we look at Google’s list, we can see how many of them do or don’t coincide with traditional training. Notice that technical ability is at the bottom and coaching is at the top. Also, productivity and flow are in the middle. In traditional training, we are the inverse with technical ability being at the top. On a certain level, we can think about how each one of Google’s traits are about a teacher's personal development and how that development enables them to be good at each of those line items. For instance, it takes years to develop the ability to have vision and think about the bigger picture (#7) and then have the ability to make the decisions to execute on those visions (#10).

Google’s list gives us insight into how to teach traditional arts to teach people of today.

Teaching others is its own journey. Good practitioners don’t necessarily make for good instructors or teachers. Being a good practitioner is its own separate journey where we are focused on making ourselves good. The journey of the one who teaches is focused on improving themselves so that they can be better at helping others to improve. What made a person technically proficient might not be the same traits which can make another person good. So, if we look at Google’s list, #1 of being able to be a good coach is about the personal development of trying to be a good teacher. Each Dan rank or teaching rank has a certain level or degree of not just responsibility but also personal development attached to it which we can then apply to each item on Google’s list.

I don’t consider myself a particularly good teacher but here are somethings I work on so that I can someday be a better and more effective instructor, leader, teacher or coach:

Study: The moment you think you know everything is the beginning of your downfall. Studying enables you to see things you might not have known or been taught when you were a student. Studying doesn’t necessarily mean books. It can also encompass learning more about how our students learn and what motivates them.

Self-awareness: Knowing who you are enables you to better serve others. Not knowing who you are could cause you to not see the other person that you are teaching and miscommunicate yourself or the art.

Communication: Someone once said, "Communication is the bridge between confusion and clarity.” If you can’t explain yourself or understand your students, how can someone expect to understand what it is you want or tell you what they need?

Honesty or truthfulness: This goes back to self-awareness. If you don’t know what the truth is, you run the risk of not being honest and then communication will break down.

Integrity: They say that integrity is the trait that ensures all others. If you are who you say you are, integrity forces you to be that person.

Etiquette: Many times, we make mistakes because we don’t know any better and accidentally offend others. A large part of etiquette is self-awareness. No one’s perfect but we should strive to be kind and graceful which is exhibited in our poise and in our manners.

Technical eye: Japanese arts about details. Details are what bring the art to life. The more we study and learn, the better the capacity we have to teach. If you are unaware, how can you see the details?

Teaching ability: There are so many different ways to teach someone something from cueing to motivational strategies. The more we learn about ourselves, our students, and our art, the more we come up with strategies to teach someone something. Anyone can teach diligent or dedicated students. The best teachers are those who can teach those who have been cast off as unteachable.   

This list isn’t exhaustive; it is just the things I think about which I hope sparks you to try to answer the question: What makes a teacher good?

Good or bad are subjective. Teaching is just the next level in a student’s development. A good teacher is a steward of the art and is supposed to be a good human being - they are also the human beings who care the most.